Cowlick’s Brandywine Tomato Review: Legendary Potato-Leaf Beefsteak

🍅 Quick take: Cowlick’s Brandywine is a classic indeterminate, mid-season potato-leaf heirloom producing 7-14 oz (200-400 g) smooth beefsteaks with tender, buttery “Brandywine-type” flesh and benchmark sweet-balanced flavor. While growers in USDA Zones 3 and 4 rave about its old-school taste, they note it dislikes extreme heat, starts setting slowly until mid-to-late summer, and sparked a lively debate here over dark-pink vs. dark-purple seed lines. Full summary ↓

Growers’ Notes and Photos (USDA Zones 3-4 Experience)

V
Valtwelve (Valery) ⭐ Pro Grower (1,846 posts)
📍 Between Samara and Ufa, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Cowlick’s Brandywine (USA).

Got the seeds purely out of curiosity to see what all the “Brandywine” hype is about, and ended up harvesting some of the best-tasting tomatoes ever. Seeds came from V. Redko. Grown in the greenhouse, just 1 plant trained to 2 stems. Tall, slender vine with wide, large potato leaves, though foliage is on the sparse side (thicker down low at around 70%, thinner up top around 30%). Responds really well to feeding, and the main stem gets thick. A single-stem plant takes up roughly 20 in (50 cm) in width. Juicy with rich, vibrant, well-balanced flavor like a good Oxheart. Easy 5+ out of 5. Pulled nearly 8 lbs (3.5 kg) off it so far, and it easily has the potential for 11 lbs (5 kg).

Edited September 28, 2020 by Drosera

Large Cowlick's Brandywine tomatoes, photo posted by Valtwelve (1)
Slicing a Cowlick's Brandywine tomato, photo posted by Valtwelve (2)
Glossy meaty flesh of Cowlick's Brandywine, photo posted by Valtwelve (3)
Cowlick's Brandywine tomato on a scale, photo posted by Valtwelve (4)

O
Oksana Evgenyevna (Oksana) ⭐ Pro Grower (5,146 posts)
📍 Aktobe, Kazakhstan (USDA Zone 4)

I agree, Cowlick’s Brandywine is a fantastic variety. Maybe only Glick’s Brandywine comes close to it on taste. Flawlessly balanced classic tomato flavor with just the right touch of sweetness. The aroma, texture, richness, and balance are benchmark level. First time I grew it was outdoors in 2019; yield wasn’t huge (probably still adjusting to my climate), though the fruits were big. I took one bite of the very first tomato and immediately scooped out the seeds to save because I loved it that much. I’m a sweet-tomato person and my dad loves classic savory flavors, and Cowlick’s blew us both away. Pure old-school tomato taste, you sink your teeth into it and that’s it… consider me hooked for life.

In 2020 I moved it into the greenhouse hoping for better yields. Definitely beat my outdoor crop, though still nothing to brag about. Our summers get brutally hot, and extreme heat wiped out fruit set across all my varieties for a good two and a half weeks. Cowlick’s is pretty slow to get going and sets much better in the second half of summer, it really dislikes extreme heat. Inside the greenhouse, the very first fruits lacked a bit of sweetness, then the flavor evened right out.

The vine is sturdy with big, heavy potato leaves, though internodes stretched a bit long in the greenhouse. You definitely need to tie up the trusses since they can kink even under a light load (though in my case, my watering schedule might’ve played a role too).

Edited November 4, 2020 by Oksana Evgenyevna

S
Shevyachok (Lyudmila) ⭐ Moderator (12,050 posts)
📍 Omsk Region, Russia (USDA Zone 3)

My Cowlick’s slice shot is practically begging to be posted here!

Meaty interior slice of Cowlick's Brandywine tomato, posted by Shevyachok

G
Galinka (Galina) ⭐ Pro Grower (3,023 posts)

Shevyachok wrote:
My Cowlick’s slice shot is practically begging to be posted here!

Gorgeous slice, making my mouth water over here.

S
SvetaR (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (27,468 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Here’s another sliced shot of this delicious beauty.

Plus a whole tomato. That’s a regular soup-style dinner plate, half-portion size, definitely not a saucer.

Large Cowlick's Brandywine tomato on a dinner plate, posted by SvetaR (1)
Sliced dark Cowlick's Brandywine tomato, posted by SvetaR (2)

T
T@tk@ (Tatyana) ⭐ Pro Grower (34,762 posts)
📍 Kazan, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

SvetaR wrote:
Here’s another sliced shot of this delicious beauty.

Svetlana, yours looks like a “black” tomato. What color is it actually supposed to be?

Mine came out pink… Maybe I grew the wrong one?

S
SvetaR (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (27,468 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Yeah, mine is definitely a dark “black” one. And judging by Lyudmila’s photo, hers is dark too.

T
T@tk@ (Tatyana) ⭐ Pro Grower (34,762 posts)
📍 Kazan, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

SvetaR wrote:
Yeah, mine is definitely a dark “black” one. And judging by Lyudmila’s photo, hers is dark too.

Just looked up the variety notes again, and they say the flesh should be dark pink. So where’d the dark seeds come from?

Anyone know where to track that strain down?

S
SvetaR (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (27,468 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

T@tk@ wrote:
So where’d the dark seeds come from?

Checked my notes and for some reason the source isn’t written down. Pretty sure my seeds came from Larisa @CUCSA, though not 100% certain.

M
Murka (Masha) ⭐ Pro Grower (9,357 posts)
📍 Nizhny Novgorod Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

COWLICK’S BRANDYWINE. Indeterminate, mid-season, potato leaf. Smooth, glossy rounded fruits, dark pink in color, averaging 7-14 oz (200-400 g). Flesh is tender, classic “Brandywine” texture you could eat with a spoon, juicy and super tasty. Got my seeds from Sofia. After trying this variety, I finally get what folks mean by “Brandywine-type flesh.”

Dark pink Cowlick's Brandywine tomato, posted by Murka

S
SvetaR (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (27,468 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Murka wrote:
dark pink in color,

Honestly, you get a different shade with every phone camera. Masha, in your photo it doesn’t look dark pink at all, more like red.

All descriptions agree on one thing though, it leans dark, whether folks call it crimson, dark pink, or a “black” tomato. Just depends how you look at it… Either way, it’s gorgeous and delicious. Mine had potato leaves too.

M
Murka (Masha) ⭐ Pro Grower (9,357 posts)
📍 Nizhny Novgorod Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

SvetaR wrote:
Honestly, you get a different shade with every phone camera. Masha, in your photo it doesn’t look dark pink at all, more like red.

Svetlana, I always try to shoot outdoors in natural light, and even then the color shifts between my phone screen and my PC. Besides, I wasn’t writing the color notes off a photo.

T
tomatinka (Vera) ⭐ Pro Grower (14,911 posts)
📍 Tyumen Region, Russia (USDA Zone 3)

Valtwelve wrote:
Cowlick’s Brandywine (USA).

What’s the actual difference compared to regular Pink Brandywine?

V
Valtwelve (Valery) ⭐ Pro Grower (1,846 posts)
📍 Between Samara and Ufa, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

tomatinka wrote:
What’s the actual difference compared to regular Pink Brandywine?

Wish I’d grown regular Pink Brandywine so I could compare, but no luck there…

Honestly, I don’t really grow Cowlick’s Brandywine anymore either, just keep finding even better varieties.

Edited January 24, 2024 by Valtwelve

Full Summary: Plant, Yield, Taste and Storage

  • 🌿 Plant: Indeterminate, mid-season, potato-leaf vine. Valtwelve noted a tall, slender vine (~20 in / 50 cm wide on a single stem) with fairly sparse foliage (thicker near the base, lighter up top) that responds well to feeding. Oksana Evgenyevna noted sturdy stems with slightly longer greenhouse internodes and trusses that need tying up to prevent kinking. Fruit size averages 7-14 oz (200-400 g).
  • 📈 Yield: Moderate and climate-sensitive. Valtwelve pulled nearly 8 lbs (3.5 kg) off a two-stem greenhouse plant with room for 11 lbs (5 kg). Oksana found it a slow starter that hates extreme heat, dropping blossoms during peak summer heatwaves and setting far better in the second half of summer.
  • 👅 Taste: Universally praised as benchmark old-school tomato flavor. Growers describe it as intensely rich, sweet yet balanced, aromatic, and tender enough to “eat with a spoon.” Note that two seed lines appear in this thread: classic deep pink/crimson and a darker “black” line grown by SvetaR and Shevyachok.
  • 📦 Storage: Not reported, though tender spoon-soft Brandywine-type flesh is typically best eaten fresh right off the counter.
  • 🌎 Who Reviewed It: Seven growers across USDA Zones 3 and 4 (Russia and Kazakhstan), with outdoor and greenhouse trials confirming it thrives once peak summer heat breaks.
👨‍🌾 Editor’s Note: Pink vs. Dark Fruit Color in This Thread
True Cowlick’s Brandywine is a classic dark rose-pink beefsteak (originally shared from a grower named Cowlick in the US). When growers in Eastern Europe get mahogany or “black” fruits under that name, it usually points to an accidental cross or a seed mix-up with True Black Brandywine or Purple Brandywine, both of which share potato leaves and rich flavor.
0 0 votes
Flavor
0 0 votes
Yield
0 0 votes
Disease Resistance
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x