🍅 Quick take: Tiffen Mennonite is a classic mid-season, indeterminate American heirloom with potato-leaf foliage (originating in Tiffin, Ohio, and featured in Carolyn Male’s 100 Heirloom Tomatoes for the American Garden). It produces 10+ oz (300+ g) oblate pink beefsteaks prized by Zone 4 growers for their juicy, tender meatiness, sweet flavor with a refreshing tang, and solid yields, even in short-season greenhouses. Full summary ↓
Growers’ Notes and Photos (USDA Zone 4 Experience)
Pretty, evenly shaped fruits with meaty beefsteak flesh and a well-balanced flavor that finishes with a refreshing tang. Juicy, thirst-quenching, and productive.
It’s an old mid-season Mennonite heirloom from the US with potato-leaf foliage and large, oblate pink slicing fruits running 10+ oz (300+ g). Featured as one of the varieties in Carolyn Male’s book 100 Heirloom Tomatoes for the American Garden.
Full Summary: Plant, Yield, Taste and Origin
- 🌿 Plant: Vigorous, mid-season indeterminate with potato-leaf foliage, reaching about 6.5 ft (2 m) in a greenhouse. Produces evenly shaped, oblate pink beefsteaks typically 10+ oz (300+ g), though fruit size can run medium depending on growing conditions.
- 📈 Yield: Good, reliable production across all three reviews.
- 👅 Taste: Meaty, juicy, tender beefsteak flesh that looks great sliced open. Sweet and well-balanced with a pleasant, refreshing tang on the finish.
- 📜 Origin: An old American Mennonite heirloom popularized by Carolyn Male in 100 Heirloom Tomatoes for the American Garden.
- 🌎 Who Reviewed It: Three growers, including two in USDA Zone 4 (Kostroma and Moscow Region), showing it performs reliably even in cooler northern climates.
🍅 Grown Tiffen Mennonite? Share your zone and how it did for you in the comments below, and add your photos!








