🏆 Most-Voted Tomato Varieties (2026 Community Tally)
Ranked by total grower mentions across all 61 Top-10 lists submitted in this thread (grouping color variants for Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum and the Butcher series).
Growers’ Individual Top-10 Tomato Lists (USDA Zones 3-7)
Hey everyone! Opening our annual Top Tomato Varieties thread. Please chime in if you’d like to share your favorites.
- Brusilovskiy
- Giant Sword
- Borisovna’s Black Heart
- Marsha’s Starfighter Beefsteak
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Khurma from Zolushka
- Natalina
- Petrovna
- Cuore di Dronero
- Mamma Mia
Edited November 9 by ezheVika
- Blazhenstvo
- Temryuk Oxheart
- Okhtyrskiye
- Paleohori
- French Grenoble Giant Antho
- Lake Svityaz
- Morado de Cabrera
- Gertrude’s Pink Splash
- Big Robutti
- Pink Paradise F1
- Lyudmila’s Delight
- Charming Tulip
- Striped Gourmet
- Castle Ghost
- Charm Street
- Summer Kiss
- Honey Grace
- Purple Brocade
- Sparkling Purple Flame
- Javelin
- Baba Tonya’s Yellow from Kabansk
- Belokurikha Orange
- Chocolate Chushka
- Dawns of Sumshchyna
- Rubtsovsk Ribbed
- Italian Stallion Yellow
- Krasavchik
- Opa Gamadrila
- Bloodstone Heliotrope
- Evening Kyiv, both versions
- Gertrude’s Pink Splash
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum Red
- Pomodoro di Nonno Eupilio
- Altai Polunitsa
- Cheryl’s Portuguese Heart
- Great Belgium
- Yaponka
- Fedor from VDNKh
- Gordon Graham’s Delicious
- Sgt. Pepper’s
- Fedor from VDNKh
- Beaurepaire
- Diva de Deva
- Zika’s Heart
- Dzinovski Jabucar
- Lobodina’s Rooster
- Gritsyk
- Butter Color
- One Trick Pony
- Chinook
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Rudnevskiye
- Nadyusha’s Large Pink
- Ukrainian Home Hearts
- Chervoni i Rozovi
- Aunt Masha
- Steak Cantu
- Rufa from Borchanochka
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum Pink
- Grun Helarios
- Gulshoda
- Golden Mountains of Medeo
- Kozula 224
- Licoria Purple
- Mille Fiori
- Oaxacan Jewel, regular leaf
- Rimma
- Tatyana’s Ruby
- Black Boomer
- Auermuom Apgue
- Cosentino sel. Claudia
- Umrilova’s Oxheart #2
- Umrilova’s Oxheart #11
- Umrilova’s Early Oxheart #13
- Grandpa’s Rooster Feather
- Kazyonnaya Zaimka
- Moravich
- Sofia’s Sweet Caramel
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Oxheart from Nice
- Costoluto Colli Euganei
- Pineapple Sergeant
- Goat Bag
- Minusinsk Champion
- Kristina Vatcheva
- Udalovs’ Oxheart
- Bychiy Lob
- Sofia’s Fiery Comet
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Rudnevskiye
- PPI
- Vorkunovskaya Shelangovskaya
- Paris
- Fatima Voronezhskaya
- Chernyy Rudnyy
- Big Robutti
- Red Dragon Heart
- Bychok Pink
- Magnitogorsk Pink
- Lidia Pavlovna
- Petrovna
- Vikulya
- Krasavchik
- Piedmont Flask
- Tree of Hearts
- Barkhattsy
- Rosy-Cheeked Nadyusha
- Matvey
- Babushkin Med
- Cherry from Zuzi
- Sofia’s Fiery Caramel
- Galaktion
- Orange Mango
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Rudnevskiye
- Tom’s Red Sliced
- Petrovna
- Otvody
- Fiery Katya
- Sofia’s Fiery Comet
- Fletch Field’s Big Yellow Matter
- Fatima
- Valkin Sovkhoz
- Vorkunovskaya Shelangovskaya
- Curtis Cheek
- Borisovna’s Black Heart with Pointed Tip
- Sofia’s Fiery Comet
- Rebel Starfighter Prime
- Sofia’s Sweet Caramel
- Orange Jazz
- Aunt Grethel’s Magic Hats
- Giant Sword
- Chocolate Stripes
- Pink from Ositsa
- Kolchak’s Gold
Really tough call, even when narrowing it down to first-time varieties I trialed this season. Way more than ten absolute winners 🤯
- Fat Robutti
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum, all three colors
- Madonna di Pasquale
- Klavdiya Eremeevskaya
- Maghreb Turban
- Feast of Colorful Depths
- Honey Passion
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Suskanskiy Pink
- Rudnevskiye
- Echo
- Elkina’s Sugar
- Swan Down
- Irish Liqueur
- Rum Baba
- Red Plum from Zhenya Polosatik
- Siebenburgen Giant
- Anna Meyer
- Big Robutti
- Cherry Syrup
- Paris
- Krasavchik
- Giovan
- Coral
- Sparkling Purple Flame
- Ram’s Bag
- French Grenoble Giant
- Kalyani
- Salute to Victoria
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum Red
- Lila
- Dad’s Red-Raspberry
- Christmas Boat
- Village from Staraya Russa
- Loved by All
- Not a Drop of Honey
- Kazakhstan Grandmas
- Zhenya Polosatik’s Plums
- Jasmina
- Timofey the Cat, wanted to stick strictly to newcomers, though it wouldn’t be fair to leave out my biggest lifesaver of the year
Photos of my top ten are over in my diary.
Edited November 11 by Khrizantema57
- Diva de Deva
- Apricot Brandywine
- Elena’s Ibiza
- Natalina F1
- Kiel’s White Heart
- Magnitogorsk Pink
- Tegucigalpa
- Auermuom Apgue
- Ibiza Beefsteak
- Kalyani
🤷♀️
- Blueberry Sherbet
- Moon Fountain F1
- PPI
- Nun’s Gift
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Madrid
- Rudnevskiye
- Timofey the Cat
- Yaponka
- Sgt. Pepper’s Raspberry Tips
- Bronze
- Pomegranate-Lemon Singapore
- Babushkin Med
- Italian Stallion
- Blue Pear
- Yellow Simpson
- West Virginia Sweets
- Yaponka
- Pink Bomb
- Cherry from Zuzi
- Striped Toad Heart
- Umrilova’s Raspberry
- Auermuom Apgue
- Mahogany
- Blazhenstvo
- Salute to Victoria
- Amethyst Heart
- Chinook
- Orange Mango
- Kalyani
- Pikalyovskiye
- Rumyanyye
- Great Belgium
- Rudnevskiye
- Anna Pavlova
- Borisovna’s Yellow Plum
- Summer Sun
- Loved by All
- Minusinsk Pickling
- Summer Sun
- Sweet Orange Ozark
- Blueberry Sherbet
- Jarson 18
- Blane’s Moonlight
- Tatyana’s Ruby
- Curtis Cheek
- All Colors of the World
- Red Mosquito
- Leprechaun Kuzya
Edited November 10 by Svetlana66
- Gourmansun
- Brusilovskiy
- Pomodoro di Nonno Eupilio
- Royal Plums
- Big Red Doll
- Giant Sword
- Petrovna
- Pink Butcher
- Khurma from Zolushka
- Sgt. Pepper’s
Edited November 10 by Zolushka
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Babushkin Med
- Granddaughter’s Joy
- Madrid
- Great Belgium
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Salute to Victoria
- Yoder’s German Pink
- Jasmina
- Cherry from Zuzi
- Kuum
- Grandpa’s Rooster Feather
- Leprechaun Sasha
- Blush
- Dzhipoliya
- Desert Heart
- Lucid Gem
- Coal Crest with Strawberry Head
- Paris
- Black with Pointed Tip
- Talgar Gem
- Raspberry Kaftan
- Red Line
- Sgt. Marley
- Morado de Cabrera
- Baba Tonya’s Wild Strawberry
- Verace
- Chilo Grosso di Salerno
- French Pineapple
- Lyovushka
- Natalina
- Elena’s Giant
- Angel’s Soul
- Almaty Orange Heart
- Baba Shura
- Pink Paradise F1
- Jasmina
- Kalyani
- Red Mosquito
- Purple from the Celestial Empire
- Japanese Oxheart
- Lyovushka
- Rumyanka’s Raspberry Heart
- Albi Beefsteak
- Lavender Lake
- Sprint Timer
- Yaponka
- Cherry Syrup
- Grishunya
- Veneto Heart
- Shuriki
- Paris
- Topklipsa
- Rebel Starfighter Kaylee Ann
Edited November 10 by Yusanka
- Purple Prize
- Christophe’s Huge
- Canary Bear
- Dwarf Grandma’s Chocolate
- Smiling Devil
- Kuma
- Solano Giant
- Ermakovskiye
- Grandma’s Heritage
- Kovlik’s Brandywine
- Permyak
- Pylayushchiy
- Altai Polunitsa
- Yaponiya
- Mulled Wine
- Lychkovskiye
- Ibirapuera Plum
- Rudnevskiye
- Zavirel
- Baton
- Zikino Srce
- Albenga Oxheart
- Belokurikha Orange
- Wolf Zossi
- Serbian Giant Yellow Heart
- Lilac Giant
- Moravich
- Rosalinda de Brebu
- Early Orange Rosalie
- Special C-TCV, often called a dwarf, though mine grew like a textbook indeterminate
- Chumatary
- Lady Brown
- Azure Giant
- Serbian Black
- Tabor Returns
- Elena’s Ibiza
- Captivating Heart
- Sofia’s Sweet Caramel
- Tatyana’s Heart
- Magic Rainbow
- Rosa de Bihor
- El Tajo
- Night Candle
- Fedor from VDNKh
- Jarson 17
- Puma
- Sparkling Purple Flame
- Violet of Cadiz
- Feast of Colorful Depths
- Galaxy Mystery
- Miracle of the Earth Ukraine
- Wolford Wonder
- Yellow Pouches
- Marmalade Lightbulb
- Folk Pear
- Yakhont
- Bendrik’s Plum, both colors
- Babushkino
- Apricot Brandywine
- Yusupovskiy
Really tough to pick just ten, so I went with my tried-and-true staples.
- Zika’s Heart
- Giant Sword
- Moravich
- Madrid F1
- Valentina Pavlovna
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Pink Garant F1
- Cesarino F1
- Natalina
- Sofia’s Fiery Comet
- Orange Mango
- Haskovski
- Giant Sword
- Strawberry Waterfall Mystery
- Borisovna’s Black Heart with Pointed Tip
- Blueberry Sherbet
- Rozova Magiya
- Brusilovskiy
- Elser Farm’s Brown Derby
Man, I really needed a top twenty 😅…
- Umrilova’s Large Square
- Umrilova’s Early Oxheart
- Umrilova’s Elongated Oxheart
- Umrilova’s Raspberry
- Martha’s Heart
- Big Red Doll
- Albi Beefsteak
- Chumatary
- Large from Khakassia
- Raspberry Kaftan
- Kievlyanka
- Malakhitovaya Shkatulka
- Valentina Pavlovna
- 100 Pudov
- Not Greater than Big Serge
- Lucid Gem
- Chocolate Stripes
- Yellow Piper
- Chocolate Fiery Crest
- Natalina
- Altai Polunitsa
- Giant Sword
- Rudnevskiye
- Jasmina
- Topklipsa
- Magnitogorsk Pink
- Sky Aces
- Dzinovski Jabucar
- Mon Amour F1
- Tretyakovskiy F1
Looking at all these lists makes you feel like you don’t have a million tomato seed packets at home and haven’t tried anything yet 😭😂 Zero to two overlaps tops.
- Blazhenstvo, huge thanks to the wonderful lady at the seed swap who handed me her leftover seeds with this gem tucked inside!
- Pineapple Heart
- Pink Crest
- Sofia’s Ginger Comet
- Giant Sword
- Pink Siberian Tiger
- Red Pear
- Brad’s Atomic Grape
- Khurma
- Yasik F1
- Moon Fountain F1
- Lobello Datterino Cherry
- Cherry Butcher
- Dzhipoliya
- Black Russian
- Provenzano
- Caostrale
- Large Pink
- Madrid F2
- Heart of Mordovia
- Yellow Cookies
- Compact Bush from Neighbor
- Albi Beefsteak
- Brusilovskiy
- Krasavchik
- Pink Butcher
- Red Butcher
- Cherry Butcher
- Teresa’s Polish Pear
- Paris
- Gourmansun
- One Trick Pony
Edited November 12 by Shevyachok
- Sofia’s Sweet Caramel
- Marmalade Lightbulb
- Giant Sword
- Lucid Gem
- Ketvel
- Grandpa from the Taiga
- Linnaeus’s Heart
- Sofia’s Sweet Caramel
- Apricot Jam
- Blushing Pineapple Sergeant
- Orange Mango
- Canadian Heritage
- Southern Tan
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Great White Blue
- Lucid Gem
- Orange Russian 117
On November 10, 2026 at 7:24 AM, Svetikk wrote:
Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum, all three colors
Oh, Svetikk, sneaky move, I can play that game too 😏
- Red & Pink Butcher
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum, all three colors 🙂
- Aunt Grethel’s Hats, both colors
- Krasavchik Pink
- Chalma Krasnaya Proletarskaya, provisional name
- Gulzhanat’s Apricot
- Pylayushchiy
- Diva de Deva
- Rudnevskiye
- Ghost / Phantom
Of course even a top 20 wouldn’t be enough. Tried to pick a varied 10 here. Favorite 5 was awesome, plus Sofia’s varieties. Didn’t even bother listing Glikeriya again since everyone’s probably sick of me talking about it 😁.
- Pink Butcher
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum Red
- Church
- Matvey
- Taiberg’s Big Plum
- Nazare
- Madeline’s Giant Tomatoes
- Lyovushka
- Ishim Heritage
- Polonez
- Blazhenstvo
- Prakhova
- Piedmont Flask
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Tajik
- Yuka’s Perfect Persimmon
- Cindy’s West Virginia
- Sudduth’s Strain Brandywine
- Verkiny
- Oxheart from Nice
- Fidelio, Sibirskiy Sad
- Podsinskoye Miracle
- Pink Grappa
- Kievlyanka
- Siberian Tiger
- Blue Pear
- Monetochka
- Grandpa from the Taiga
- Helen
- Mashtaginskiye
From varieties new to me:
- Canary
- Steak Cantu
- Baba Shura
- Rebel Starfighter VT-16
- Amethyst Heart
- Kiel’s White Heart
- Giant Sword
- Elfie
- Bronze Heart of an Angel
- Salute to Victoria, plus every Sofia variety I grew
- Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum Pink
- Shimblenk
- Large from Cluj
- Nazare
- Cherry from Zuzi
- Dzhipoliya
- Ghost
- Great Belgium
- Ketvel
- Baba Tonya’s from Kabansk
10 is way too few, barely any of my favorites fit on here.
My top favorite tomatoes, permanent residency in the greenhouse 🙂
- Sweet Beet
- Jasmina
- Martha’s Heart
- Big Red Doll
- Romanian Red, for yield and huge fruit size
- Pineapple Sergeant
- Canadian Heritage
- Midnight Sun
- African Liana
- Polaris
- Podsinskoye Miracle
- Marmalade Lightbulb
- Bob’s Heart
- Sgt. Pepper’s Bronze Fingers
- Salute to Victoria
- Ketvel
- Red Butcher
- Big Robutti
- Diva de Deva
- Granddaughter’s Joy
- Nazare
- Ramzes
- Yaven’s Pink Giant
- Rudnevskiye
- Evgeniya
- Ideal Beauty
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Natalina
- Jasmina
- Sergeant Pascal
- Yaponiya
- Pashka’s Favorite Hearts
- Lake Maggiore
- Blackberry
- Moire Sunset
- Pink Margari
Edited Tuesday at 10:34 PM by YaElena
- Granddaughter’s Joy
- Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon)
- Cuneo Giant Pear
- Pessac Pink Striped Heart
- Orange Orangutan
- Grandpa Tikhon
- Elena’s Ibiza
- Cuban Salami
- Aunt Grethel’s Magic Hats
- Angolskiye
Full Summary: Key Trends from the 2026 Tomato Poll
- 🏆 Unstoppable Heavyweights: Large-fruited, flavorful heirlooms dominated the 2026 ballots, led by Rudnevskiye (10), Giant Sword (9), Surovaya Dynya (Volga German Harsh Melon) (9), and Valentina Pavlovna (8).
- 🎨 Bred by Sofia Saakova: Russian breeder Sofia Saakova’s colorful antho and striped lines had huge representation across multiple lists, especially Sofia’s Sweet Caramel (5), Sofia’s Fiery Comet (4), and Sofia’s Ginger Comet, with irina.pojarka even nominating “every Sofia variety I grew.”
- ❤️ US & European Classics Still Shine: Aunt Swarlo’s Polish Plum (Red, Pink, and all-color picks across 7 growers), Lucid Gem (4), Sgt. Pepper’s variants, Chocolate Stripes, Brandywine strains, and Rebel Starfighter Prime held strong alongside newer European selections like Big Robutti, Madrid, and Diva de Deva.
- 🌱 Standout Hybrids: While open-pollinated heirlooms made up over 90% of picks, Natalina (7 mentions including F1), Pink Paradise F1, Pink Garant F1, and Moon Fountain F1 proved reliable enough to crack growers’ Top 10s.
- 🌎 Wide Climate Proof: Lists came from growers across USDA Zones 3 through 7 (Siberia, the Urals, Moscow, Belarus, and southern Russia), showing strong cross-climate consistency for the top picks.


