Elser Farm’s Brown Derby Review & Photos

Share your rating
🍅 Quick take: Elser Farm’s Brown Derby is an indeterminate beefsteak with a unique greenish-ochre to brownish-orange skin and vibrant tricolor flesh. Growers consistently praise its sweet, rich, and slightly tangy flavor, often comparing it to a ripe mango or the famous Dwarf Uluru Ochre. While it’s an indeterminate vine, most growers note it stays relatively compact (around 5 ft / 1.5 m), making it great for side rows in a greenhouse. Yields are reported as high, especially when given plenty of sun. Full summary ↓

Growers’ Notes and Photos

S
Svetikk (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (29,423 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Elser Farm’s Brown Derby. Indeterminate. The vine was vigorous, grew it in the greenhouse and it was doing great at first. But then it got too much nitrogen and started dropping blossoms because of the weather (constant rain and high humidity). Since it was shaded due to tight spacing, I pruned the plant heavily, leaving only the bottom truss where just one single fruit survived, just enough for me to taste it. Seeds came from SvetaR with the highest recommendations as her sweetest and most delicious variety from last season.

Beautiful oblate shape, greenish-ochre color with an orange tint inside. Weighed about 12.3 oz (350 g). Buttery flesh, very good flavor but with a decent amount of tartness. Dwarf Uluru Ochre is still better though! 🤭

Didn’t save many seeds, only got them from this one mater.

Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato, photo posted by Svetikk (1)
Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato, photo posted by Svetikk (2)

O
Olga39 (Olga) ⭐ Grower (215 posts)
📍 Kaliningrad, Russia (USDA Zone 6)
Grew this one in 2019. In my opinion, it’s a very worthy and interesting variety with a rich and complex flavor. Every single truss ripened for me. The taste actually evolved as I harvested the higher trusses, going from good to absolutely outstanding.Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato, photo posted by Olga39 (1)
Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato, photo posted by Olga39 (2)
T
Tatka (Tatyana) ⭐ Pro Grower (35,139 posts)
📍 Kazan, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Svetikk said:
Elser Farm’s Brown Derby… I pruned the plant heavily, leaving only the bottom truss where just one single fruit survived, just enough for me to taste it…

Sveta, did you happen to regrow this one this year?

S
Svetikk (Svetlana) ⭐ Pro Grower (29,423 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Tatka said:
Sveta, did you happen to regrow this one this year?

No, I wanted to but I only have a few seeds left. I did regrow my favorite Dwarf Uluru Ochre though. And a segregation I got from Cresta di Fuoco turned out very similar in both color and taste.

I
Irina Fedorova ⭐ Pro Grower (1,660 posts)
📍 Kaliningrad, Russia (USDA Zone 6)
Grew Brown Derby this year, really liked it. The vine isn’t super tall, but it’s sturdy with massive leaves. Trusses don’t kink, and it threw out both large and medium fruits. Absolutely loved the flavor, honestly didn’t seem any worse than my beloved Uluru. Once again, forgot to take pictures.
P
Petrofka (Natalya) ⭐ Pro Grower (8,068 posts)
📍 Nizhny Novgorod, Russia (USDA Zone 4)
You gotta want it. First variety to hit my wishlist for the new season 🤦‍♀️
F
FLOKSA (Olga) ⭐ Grower (397 posts)
Absolutely love this gorgeous variety. Been growing it for quite a while now. Seeds originally came from Marinessa. It doesn’t grow too tall for me, so it’s perfect to tuck along the greenhouse wall. The flesh is buttery and very unique. And the flavor is sweet with some special twist to it. If there are similar varieties out there, I definitely want to try them. As of today, Elser Farm’s Brown Derby stands way out from the rest of my tomatoes.
V
Verusik1982 (Vera) ⭐ Newbie (13 posts)
Hey folks, I ordered seeds for this beauty this year. What’s the maturity on it, mid-season? I’m really tight on space, so I’m guessing it needs to be as close to the sun as possible? I only have one spot left for either Uluru or this one. Which one should I actually plant? Thinking about sticking it on the sunny side of the greenhouse.
F
FLOKSA (Olga) ⭐ Grower (397 posts)

Verusik1982 said:
Thinking about sticking it on the sunny side of the greenhouse.

That’s exactly how it grows for me every year, in the second row but facing the sun. Didn’t bake at all in this extreme summer heat. Definitely not an early variety though.

I
Irina Volga (Irina Rubleva) ⭐ Pro Grower (902 posts)
📍 Volgograd, Russia (USDA Zone 6/7)
Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato harvest, photo posted by Irina Volga
T
TatyanaSh (Tatyana) ⭐ Pro Grower (5,471 posts)
📍 Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

My Derby. Flavor-wise, it’s my biggest discovery this year. There are tasty tomatoes, and then there’s this one, it’s just something special. The flesh is tender, almost like a ripe mango, with a bright zippy tang to it. You just want to eat this slicer raw, without any salt or spices, just like a treat. So incredibly good!Mine turned out mid-sized (definitely better to plant it on the edge of the greenhouse) and mid-late season. Weights were around 7-14 oz (200-400 g). The color in the photo didn’t translate perfectly, it’s more of an ochre in real life.

Huge props to @SvetaR for the seeds, thank you!

Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato slice, photo by TatyanaSh (1)
Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato on scale, photo by TatyanaSh (2)

A
Anela (Elena) ⭐ Pro Grower (3,218 posts)
📍 Kazan, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Olga39 said:
In my opinion, it’s a very worthy and interesting variety with a rich and complex flavor…

Who did you buy your seeds from?

O
Olga39 (Olga) ⭐ Grower (215 posts)
📍 Kaliningrad, Russia (USDA Zone 6)

Anela said:
Who did you buy your seeds from?

Bought the seeds from Danko. Why do you ask, are there different strains of “Derby” out there?

A
Anela (Elena) ⭐ Pro Grower (3,218 posts)
📍 Kazan, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

Olga39 said:
Bought the seeds from Danko. Why do you ask…

Your photos are just beautiful.

O
Olga39 (Olga) ⭐ Grower (215 posts)
📍 Kaliningrad, Russia (USDA Zone 6)

Anela said:
Your photos are just beautiful.

It grew on the south side of the greenhouse, soaking up the sun 🙂

V
Verusik1982 (Vera) ⭐ Newbie (13 posts)
Big thanks, y’all. We aren’t huge fans of tart tomatoes, but I’ll plant one vine just to test it out.
F
FLOKSA (Olga) ⭐ Grower (397 posts)

Here is the coloring I get! Never gets as bright as the photos above. But the flavor is always a bomb!Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato harvest, photo by FLOKSA

M
Murka (Masha) ⭐ Pro Grower (9,772 posts)
📍 Nizhny Novgorod Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)

One of my absolute favorite ochre-colored varieties. The flesh is dense, buttery, and incredibly delicious. Fruits are huge, around 10.5-14 oz (300-400 g).It’s an indet vine, reaches about 5 ft (1.5 m) and does great in a side bed.

Elser Farm's Brown Derby tomato on vine, photo by Murka

E
Ellis_Cu (Tatyana) ⭐ Grower (131 posts)
📍 Kolomna, Moscow Region, Russia (USDA Zone 4)
Grew this one this year. Super delicious variety with sugary flesh, the plant was absolutely loaded. Grew it outdoors under an awning. Turned out crazy productive! Loved it so much, probably the best new-to-me variety this season.Elser Farm's Brown Derby sliced tomato, photo by Ellis_Cu (1)
Elser Farm's Brown Derby sliced tomato, photo by Ellis_Cu (2)

Full Summary: Plant, Yield, Taste and Growing Tips

  • 🌿 Plant: Indeterminate, mid-late season. While it is a vining type, multiple growers across Zones 4 and 6 note that it doesn’t grow overly tall. It typically reaches about 5 ft (1.5 m), making it an excellent candidate for planting along the side walls of a greenhouse. The foliage is sturdy with large leaves.
  • 🍅 Fruit: Large beefsteaks ranging from 7 to 14 oz (200-400 g). The skin is a unique greenish-ochre, while the interior flesh features an orange or brownish tint.
  • 📈 Yield: Rated very highly by growers when given enough sun. It produces well both in greenhouses and outdoors (often grown under simple awnings in shorter seasons).
  • 👅 Taste: Universally praised. The flesh is described as buttery, dense, and sugary, with a complex flavor profile that includes a zippy, fruity tang (one grower compared it to ripe mango). It is frequently compared favorably to the famous Dwarf Uluru Ochre.
  • 💡 Growing Tips: It loves sunlight. Due to its slightly more compact indeterminate habit, growers recommend planting it in the second row or near the sunny edges of a greenhouse. Be cautious with early nitrogen applications to prevent blossom drop.
0 0 votes
Flavor
0 0 votes
Yield
0 0 votes
Disease Resistance
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x